Explore Our Products
Discover the diverse and delectable flavors at Middletown Creamery. From classic favorites to innovative creations, each scoop is crafted with fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Whether you're craving something familiar or adventurous, our menu has something for everyone.
Why Our Ice Creams are
Great
At Middletown Creamery, our ice cream flavors stand out for their exceptional quality, creativity, and dedication to satisfying every palate. We take pride in offering a range of flavors that are fresh, flavorful, and meticulously crafted.
Here are three reasons why our ice cream flavors are truly outstanding:
Fresh Ingredients
We use only the freshest, locally sourced ingredients in our ice cream. By partnering with local farmers and suppliers, we ensure that every batch is made with high-quality, natural ingredients. This commitment to freshness results in vibrant, authentic flavors that you can taste in every bite.
Diverse Flavors
Our diverse menu includes classic favorites and innovative seasonal creations. Whether you're a fan of traditional flavors or looking for something new and exciting, we have something to satisfy your cravings. Our flavor combinations are thoughtfully crafted to provide a unique and delightful experience with every scoop.
Artisanal Quality
Our ice cream is made in small batches using artisanal methods. This hands-on approach allows us to maintain the highest standards of quality and texture. Each scoop is carefully churned and crafted to achieve the perfect balance of creaminess and flavor, ensuring a consistently excellent product.
All Products
Ice Creams
Indulge in our artisanal ice creams, crafted with fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Our diverse menu offers classic favorites and unique flavors, ensuring a delightful experience for every palate. Each scoop promises rich, creamy texture and vibrant taste, making Middletown Creamery the perfect destination for ice cream lovers.
Milk Shakes
Experience the ultimate refreshment with our delicious milk shakes, made from our premium ice creams. Blended to perfection, our milk shakes come in a variety of flavors, offering a creamy, smooth, and satisfying treat. Enjoy a delightful burst of flavor in every sip at Middletown Creamery.
Coffee
Enjoy our freshly brewed coffee, made with premium beans, offering a rich, aromatic experience to complement your ice cream treat.
Cookies
Savor our delicious cookies, baked fresh daily, and perfect for pairing with your favorite ice cream flavors or enjoying on their own.
Treats
Discover a variety of delightful treats, including brownies and pastries, all crafted to add an extra layer of sweetness to your visit.
Available Flavors
Banana
Birthday Cake
Black Raspberry
Black Raspberry Chip
Butter Brickle
Butter Pecan
Cappuccino Crunch
Cherry Vanilla
Chocolate
Chocolate Almond
Choco Chip Cookie Dough
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Choco Chip P.B. Swirl
Chocolate Thunder
Coconut
Coffee
Cotton Candy
Dirt
Motor Oil
Peppermint Chip
Peach (Seasonal)
Pumpkin (Seasonal)
Salted Caramel
Strawberry
SORBETS
Mango, Lemon, Raspberry
Special Toppings
Cherries
Peanuts
M&M’s
Banana
Gummy Bears
Reese’s Pieces
Pineapple
Hot Fudge
Crushed Oreos
Peanut Butter
Caramel
Whipped Cream
Chocolate Chips
Strawberry Syrup
Rainbow Sprinkles
Chocolate Sprinkles
Caramelized Walnuts
Chopped Strawberries
Brownie Pieces
Cheesecake Pieces
Strawberry Preserves
Choco Chip Cookie Dough Pcs.
COOKIES
Sugar
Chocolate Chunk
Double Chocolate
White Chocolate
Macademia
