Experience the ultimate refreshment with our milk shakes, expertly blended from our premium ice creams. At Middletown Creamery, we take pride in creating milk shakes that are the perfect balance of creaminess and flavor. Each milk shake starts with our rich, creamy ice cream, which is blended with just the right amount of milk to achieve a smooth, velvety texture.

We offer a wide variety of flavors to satisfy every palate, from classic chocolate and strawberry to unique combinations like lemon blueberry. Our milk shakes are designed to be a satisfying treat, whether you’re enjoying them as a dessert or a midday pick-me-up. For those who love a little extra, we offer add-ons like whipped cream, sprinkles, and even cookie crumbles to make your milk shake experience even more indulgent. At Middletown Creamery, we believe that every sip should be a burst of deliciousness, which is why we use only the freshest, highest quality ingredients in our milk shakes.