Savor the taste of our freshly baked cookies, perfect for pairing with our ice creams or enjoying on their own. At Middletown Creamery, we believe that the perfect cookie starts with high-quality ingredients, which is why we use only the best in our baking. Our cookies come in a variety of flavors, from classic chocolate chip to indulgent double chocolate and everything in between.

Each cookie is baked to perfection, offering a deliciously soft and chewy texture with a satisfying crunch. Our bakers take great care to ensure that every cookie is just right, with the perfect balance of sweetness and flavor. Whether you’re enjoying a cookie as a quick snack, as part of a dessert, or with a cup of our freshly brewed coffee, you’ll love the rich, comforting flavors that our cookies provide. We also offer seasonal cookie flavors, so there’s always something new and exciting to try. At Middletown Creamery, our cookies are more than just a treat—they’re a way to bring a little extra joy to your day.